Brooklyn Bedding’s Best Mattresses of 2024

In today’s fast-paced world, quality sleep is more crucial than ever. The mattress industry has responded with innovative designs and advanced technologies, offering various options to meet all your sleep needs. With so many choices available, it can be overwhelming to know where to start when choosing a new mattress that suits you best.

In this guide, we’ll explore the importance of sleep quality and how to choose a mattress to fit your sleep style. We’ll also look at Brooklyn Bedding’s best mattresses of 2024, highlighting their unique features, benefits, and what sets them apart in a vast marketplace. From luxury hybrids to budget-friendly picks, our curated list is designed to help you find the perfect match for your individual sleep needs.

Importance of Sleep Quality

What is Sleep Quality?

Sleep quality isn't just about how many hours you sleep each night, it’s also about how efficiently you sleep, how quickly you fall asleep, and how often you wake up. Ideally, you should spend at least 85% of your time in bed sleeping and you should look to fall asleep within 30 minutes of hitting the pillow. Good sleep quality also means waking up no more than once a night (or twice if you're over 65). If you have a sleep disorder, it’s a good idea to talk with your doctor about how to improve your sleep. For more information on sleep disorders, like insomnia, check out our Sleep Science Blog here. 

How to Improve Sleep Quality

Improving sleep quality involves adopting a few key habits that promote better rest. Start by maintaining a consistent sleep schedule. This should include going to bed and waking up at the same time every day, even on the weekends. Create a relaxing bedtime routine, such as reading or taking a warm bath, to signal to your body that it’s time to wind down. Ensure your bedroom sets the mood for rest: keep the room cool, dark, and quiet. Avoid screens and bright lights in the evening, and steer clear of caffeine and heavy meals before bed. Regular exercise and stress management can also make a big difference. Most importantly, invest in a comfortable mattress and pillows to get the most out of your sleep!

Benefits of Quality Sleep

Good quality sleep is essential for your overall health and well-being, offering numerous benefits that extend beyond just feeling rested. Quality sleep enhances cognitive function, improving decision-making, reaction time, judgment, attention, and problem-solving skills. It also plays a huge role in physical health by repairing cells in the body, aiding in weight management, and regulating hormones and metabolic processes. Additionally, good sleep helps promote mental and emotional stability by reducing the risk of mood disorders, improving psychological resilience, and increasing positive mental outlook. By prioritizing sleep, you can expect to see an increase in energy levels and productivity, leading to a more balanced, fulfilling life. 

Factors to Consider When Buying a Mattress

Firmness

Before we dive deeper into mattress buying, one question needs to be answered: what is firmness? Mattress firmness is how soft or hard a mattress feels when you lie on it. It is often measured on a scale ranging from soft to extra firm. Most mattress brands use a scale from 1 to 10 to clarify how firm or soft a mattress is, with 10 being the most firm.

It's important to understand that mattress firmness is subjective; what feels extra firm to one person might be perceived as soft by another. Given that firmness is subjective, it's crucial to find a firmness level that aligns with your sleep position and weight to ensure optimal support and comfort. A firmer mattress will provide that extra support to maintain proper spinal alignment throughout the night, reducing the risk of waking up with aches and pain. 

Support Levels

When choosing a mattress, prioritize one that provides excellent support, especially for your lower back and hips, which are more sensitive to discomfort during sleep. Factors such as your weight, height, and sleep position are crucial in determining the appropriate support level. For instance, a firm mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers because it provides the necessary support to prevent the lower back from sinking in, reducing the risk of back pain and ensuring that the hips and spine remain aligned throughout the night.

If you’re a side sleeper, a firm mattress might not be the best choice due to the increased pressure points at the shoulders and hips. These areas hold more weight and pressure when lying on your side, which can lead to discomfort and pain. A softer mattress allows these pressure points to sink in slightly, distributing body weight more evenly and reducing stress on these areas.

Sleep Position

Earlier, we mentioned things like firmness and support levels that are dependent on how you sleep, also known as your sleep position. But what exactly is a sleep position and how does it affect the mattress you buy? Most mattress companies break down sleep positions into four different styles: back sleepers, side sleepers, stomach sleepers, or combination sleepers. Figuring out your sleep position is the first step in figuring out which mattress is right for you.

Back Sleepers

Back sleepers need a mattress that supports their whole body, especially the spine. Avoid mattresses that are too soft, as they can cause back pain from sinking in too much. If you weigh under 250 pounds, a medium-firmness mattress is ideal because it supports your shoulders and lower back while cradling your spine's natural arch. For those over 250 pounds, a firm mattress, or even a plus-size option, is best. The goal is to provide solid support for your whole body, including the spine, considering the extra weight’s impact on the mattress.

Side Sleepers

If you’re a side sleeper, you need your mattress to relieve pressure on your shoulders, hips, and knees, spreading your weight evenly. Most average-sized side sleepers love a medium-firmness because it offers good support while contouring the body. If you’re on the lighter side, under 130 pounds, a medium mattress might feel like you’re sleeping on top of it. For better pressure relief, lighter sleepers should go for a softer mattress. 

Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers have their own set of challenges with keeping their spine aligned and neck supported. If you’re a stomach sleeper, you need a mattress that spreads your weight evenly and avoids too much curve in the spine. If you weigh under 250 pounds, a medium mattress will give you a nice, level surface with enough support. But if you’re over 250 pounds, go for a firm mattress– it provides a level surface too, but with less sink, which is better for heavier bodies to keep the spine aligned. A thinner, low-profile pillow is also a good option for stomach sleepers to ensure the neck and spine are aligned while sleeping. 

Combination Sleepers

Most combo sleepers switch between their sides and stomachs, stomachs and back, or a combination of all three during the night. No matter your weight, a medium mattress is the way to go. It keeps your spine aligned in all your favorite sleep positions and offers excellent pressure relief for your shoulders and hips. Even if you roll onto your stomach, avoid a firm mattress– it’s not the best fit for combination sleepers. Pay attention to the position you fall asleep and wake up in– this will help you choose the right pillow to complement your most dominant sleep position!

Materials

When it comes to getting great sleep, you know what you like best. If you’ve loved a firm mattress for years, you’ll probably still prefer it. With so many new materials and technologies, it’s a great time to explore your options. If you’re unsure, a good mattress company (like ours) can help you find the perfect fit based on your sleep needs.

Innerspring and Hybrid Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses come in two main types: traditional and hybrid. Traditional innerspring mattresses have a grid of coils covered with padding, while hybrid mattresses, like the Brooklyn Signature, use individually encased springs to reduce motion transfer and provide support. Hybrids often have foam layers on top for added comfort and cooling. 

High-quality hybrid mattresses use individually encased coils, which are great for couples because they reduce motion transfer and enhance support. These mattresses also allow for better airflow, keeping you cooler at night. Hybrids are versatile, offering targeted pressure relief with various foams and surface treatments. They also have strong edge support thanks to heavier gauge coils around the perimeter. Look for zoned coils to get the best support for your shoulders, hips, and back.

Both traditional and hybrid mattresses are generally more affordable than other types, though high-end hybrid mattresses with advanced materials can be pricier.

All-Foam Mattresses

All-foam mattresses offer various features and benefits. Some use one or two types of foam, while others have up to five layers. More layers mean better support, smoother transitions, and improved breathability. The Indentation Load Deflection (ILD) of the foam layers is crucial in determining the mattress's firmness and comfort level. A higher ILD indicates a firmer feel, while a lower ILD feels softer. Additionally, the density of the foam, measured in pounds per cubic foot (LBS), significantly impacts the mattress’s durability and support. Higher-density foams (with higher LBS) generally offer greater longevity and support, while lower-density foams may provide a softer, more plush feel. A high-density core can ensure long-lasting stability and durability.

The Three Foam Types

Both all-foam and hybrid mattresses can be constructed of different types of foam. More advanced mattress construction will offer key benefits like cooling gel infusions to moderate sleep temperature but, generally speaking, there are three basic types of foam.

Quick Response Foams

Quick response foams are exactly that– meaning they respond more quickly to movement. Consequently, these foams are great for sleepers who want contouring pressure point relief but want to avoid the sinking feeling of memory foam.

Our supreme response foam and VariFlex foam are examples of the quick response foams we use in the construction of our mattresses. It’s naturally breathable, making it an excellent choice for hot sleepers and those who suffer from night sweats. Quick response foams also offer a distinctive blend of pressure point relief with a “sleep-on-top” feel that’s less extreme than latex. Overall, quick response foams provide a “just right” feel that is the most universally preferred of all foams. 

Slow Response Foams

Memory foam, like that found in the Dreamfoam Essential, is considered a slow-response foam. Best-in-class for motion isolation, memory foam beds are great for couples who want uninterrupted sleep, even if a partner is tossing and turning.

Since memory foam is a slow-response foam, memory foam mattresses are a good choice for light sleepers who have trouble getting comfortable. 

Memory foam is highly adaptable to the body's curves, making it particularly good for side sleepers and people with chronic pain near pressure points. Because of their enhanced contouring properties, memory foams tend to trap heat more than quick-response foams or latex. Always look for cooling gel treatments or cool gel infusions in memory foam to ensure optimal temperature moderation. Gel swirl memory foam is another name for slow-response foam that has cooling benefits “swirled” into the mattress’s foam layer.

Overall, slow-response foams are for sleepers who like a BIG hug when they sleep!

Latex Foams

Latex foam is in a class all by itself. It's uniquely buoyant, resulting in the highest responsiveness to movement, and comes from greater elasticity. Those who are passionately in favor of latex foam usually gravitate towards the material because of its tremendous pressure point relief, breathability, and resilience.

Latex foam can be natural, synthetic, or a blend of both. Natural latex is derived from the sap of rubber trees, which is a renewable source.

Overall, a latex mattress is an excellent choice for sleepers who want the truest “sleep-on-top” feel. Natural latex is also preferred by those with skin sensitivities or who are looking for environmentally friendly materials in beds like the EcoSleep by Brooklyn Bedding. 

Unique Sleep Needs

After reviewing the key factors in choosing a mattress, let’s see if you have any unique sleep needs. Here are some options that you should consider when you might not have thought about it before:

Extra Firm Sleep

If you find sleeping on the floor more comfortable than your mattress, you might need an extra firm mattress. Ideal for those with back pain, stomach or back sleepers, and people with arthritis or osteoporosis, an extra firm mattress keeps your spine in a neutral position, reducing pressure on your joints and improving posture. It also boosts circulation and oxygen intake. The Plank by Brooklyn Bedding is perfect for those who can’t find a mattress firm enough. For more information on if extra firm sleep is right for you, check out the Firm Mattress Buying Guide. 

Plus-Size Sleep

Your weight is a key factor in finding the right mattress. Studies show that heavier individuals benefit from thicker and firmer mattresses. Plus-size sleepers often face issues like:

• Middle sag
• Softening of the sleep surface
• Decreased edge support
• Uneven support distribution
• Night sweats
• Increased motion transfer

The Titan by Brooklyn Bedding is designed with these unique needs in mind, offering extra durability and lift.

Snuggle-Friendly Solutions

Is your partner keeping you up at night? Outside of accidental sleep kicking, motion transfer is a common issue, whether from getting in and out of bed, tossing and turning, or movement disorders that partners experience while sleeping. A hybrid mattress with multiple foam layers and individually encased coils can minimize motion transfer. Alternatively, consider a larger mattress or even a split California King to reduce disturbances and ensure a restful night’s sleep.

Sleep Technology

Enhancing your sleep experience has never been easier with the latest advancements in mattress technology. Here are two standout innovations designed to improve comfort and overall sleep quality:

Adjustable Bases

Adjustable bases allow you to customize your sleep position with ease. Whether watching TV, reading, or looking to relieve pressure points, these bases provide the support and flexibility you need for optimal comfort. Elevate your head, legs, or both to find the perfect position that suits your nightly routine and health needs. Just be careful not to sandwich yourself!

GlacioTex™ Cooling Fiber

Stay cool throughout the night with GlacioTex™, a cutting-edge cooling fiber infused into the top layer of your mattress. This technology helps regulate your body temperature, preventing overheating and ensuring a consistently cool and comfortable sleep. Ideal for those who tend to sleep hot, GlacioTex™ transforms your mattress into a refreshing oasis for restful nights. 

How We Selected the Best Mattresses

To find the best mattresses of 2024, we put in the work so you don’t have to! Our team of sleep experts and real-world testers tried out each mattress, assessing how well they catered to different sleep needs and preferences. From materials and construction to customer reviews and industry awards, we left no stone unturned in our quest to bring you the top mattresses that will get you the best sleep possible.

Top Mattresses of 2024

Signature Hybrid - Best Value Hybrid Mattress

When it comes to an affordable, high-quality mattress, the Signature Hybrid is at the top of the list. It features aof responsive foam and individually encased coils, providing excellent support and pressure relief. The mattress includes a cooling gel layer to regulate temperature, making it comfortable for a wide range of sleepers. It also comes in various customization options; offering three firmness options and 14 size options. 

Highlights of the Signature Hybrid Mattress

• Back sleepers will appreciate the proprietary foams and individually wrapped coils, which provide a perfect mix of comfort and support.
• It is a great choice for those with back pain, as it promotes a healthy sleep posture.
• The foam and coal combination offers the right amount of responsiveness, making it easy for combination sleepers to change positions.
• Impressive edge support is a big plus for those who sleep near the edge of the bed.
• It is very affordable, with a queen mattress coming in at under $1,000 after discounts.

What to Keep in Mind

• Side sleepers will need the Soft version of the Signature Hybrid, which provides a bit more pressure relief (especially if they experience joint pain).
• If you’re a heavy back or stomach sleeper who needs extra support, check out the Titan Plus.

Aurora Luxe - Best Cooling Mattress

The Aurora Luxe Hybrid mattress is perfect for staying cool while you sleep, especially for people who sleep hot. Its cover is literally cool to the touch, and the inclusion of gel- and copper-infused foam, along with the pocketed coils, help keep air flowing so you don’t overheat. Hot sleepers will love it, and it has a soft, cozy feel like pricier luxury hybrids (but it doesn’t have that luxury price tag). Customers, especially couples, love how cool it stays, even with two people. Many recommend adding the Cloud Pillow Top for extra cushioning. It’s great for motion isolation and is still responsive enough so it’s not a struggle to switch sleep positions.

Highlights of the Aurora Luxe

• Since we own our factory, you can get this luxury mattress at a fraction of what the other guys charge.
• Three different firmness options: Soft, Medium, and Firm. We offer customized comfort designed for your sleep style.
• Comfort layers are excellent at motion isolation, but are still responsive enough to move without feeling stuck.

What to Keep in Mind

• People who weigh over 250 pounds are better off looking at the Titan Plus for additional support

Sedona Elite - Best Luxury Mattress

The Sedona Elite is a hybrid bed-in-a-box mattress with a soft, pillow-top feel due to its multiple layers of copper-infused, slow-response memory foam. It provides excellent pressure relief and low-motion transfer, making it a great option for side sleepers, couples, and those with shoulder pain. The Sedona Elite would be best for side sleepers or people with hip or shoulder pain. Since the mattress is on the softer side, it allows side sleepers to sink in, allowing pressure to be alleviated on these sensitive areas. The motion isolation is top-notch, so your partner’s movements won’t disturb you. 

Highlights of the Sedona Elite

• It is best for side sleepers or those with hip or shoulder pain. The Sedona Elite's extra cushioning design helps alleviate these sensitive areas for optimal pressure-relieving comfort.
• Its copper-infused foam keeps the mattress as cool as possible while also providing antimicrobial benefits, protecting you from bacteria, viruses, and more while you sleep.
• Couples could also benefit from this mattress due to its low-motion transfer. Those nights of waking up to your partner moving are over!

What to Keep in Mind

• If you’re a stomach sleeper, you might want to consider a firmer mattress. The softness of the Sedona Elite allows your hips to sink in more as a stomach sleeper, so something firmer would be more supportive for your sleep style. We’d recommend checking out the Aurora Luxe in Firm.
• Heavier sleepers might also want to avoid this mattress because it lacks the extra support they might need. If you want a softer-feeling mattress with all the support a heavier sleeper could need, check out the Titan Plus Luxe.
• This mattress is on the pricier side if you have a specific budget, with a Queen model starting at $1799 with discounts. If you’re looking for a high-quality mattress under $1000, check out the Signature Hybrid.

Plank Firm - Best Firm Mattress for Back Pain

Firm mattresses are great for back sleepers, stomach sleepers, heavier individuals, and those with back pain. The Plank Firm is a unique, flippable mattress that gives you that firm “on top of” feel. The flippable design of the Plank Firm sports two sides of varying firmness levels; on one side, you have a “firm” side (an 8 on the firmness scale), and on the other, you have the “ultra-firm” side (a 10 on the firmness scale). Anything firmer than this would be an ACTUAL plank. Despite its firmness, the Plank Firm remains comfortable with its cushioning top foams and quilted material. It's perfect for stomach sleepers, providing the necessary support to keep your hips aligned with your shoulders. 

Highlights of the Plank Firm

• The “on top of” feel, and responsiveness of the Plank Firm, make it ideal for combination sleepers.
• Endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), means that the Plank Firm’s support reduces spinal stress, improves lumbar support, and helps alleviate back pain.
• It’s an all-foam bed with a fantastic ability to isolate motion. This is a big win for anyone who sleeps with a partner or their pet(s)!
• Despite it being an all-foam bed, the edge support is top-notch. No sinking or sliding off the side of the bed will happen here.

What to Keep in Mind

• If you’re a side sleeper, the Plank Firm mattress is not the best choice. Opt for a softer mattress to avoid pressure buildup in the shoulders and hips.

Titan Plus - Best Mattress for Heavy People

The Titan Plus is a hybrid mattress built for big, tall, and strong sleepers. Made for those over 250 pounds, the Titan Plus is made with high-density foam and individually wrapped coils to offer optimal support for heavier individuals, as well as average-weight back and stomach sleepers. This durable mattress resists sagging, providing a supportive surface across the entire bed. The top foam layer of the Titan Plus is gel-infused and made to draw heat away from the body. You can also add the GlacioTex™ Cooling Cover for an additional cooling boost. The Titan Plus is the most affordable plus-size mattress on the market. With a Queen priced at $1249 (with discounts), it’s significantly cheaper than its competitors, typically costing $1549 or more. 

Highlights of the Titan Plus

• Superior edge support and motion isolation. The Titan Plus’ strong perimeter ensures you don’t feel like you’re sliding off. If you sleep with a partner, the Titan Plus’ motion isolation also ensures that you don’t feel them moving around!
• Ideal for heavy people who may have back problems, offering that additional lower body alignment while still having a comfortable feel. 
• Customers appreciate the high quality and level of durability at a more affordable price.

What to Keep in Mind

• Not ideal for lightweight sleepers as it might be too firm. A good recommendation would be to find a mattress with varying firmness options, like the Signature Hybrid or the Aurora Luxe, so you can maximize your comfort and support based on your weight.
• If you’re a plus-size side sleeper, we recommend checking out the Titan Plus Luxe. It has a softer feeling without losing out on any support.

BB Kids - Best Nontoxic Kids Mattress

BB Kids is a newer mattress from the Brooklyn Bedding lineup. It’s a budget-friendly, firm memory foam mattress that features Nano Stain Terminator technology to guard against splashes, spills, and permanent stains. BB Kids is a fiberglass-free and hypoallergenic mattress (which is a fancy way to say non-toxic). The gel swirl memory foam top offers immediate responsiveness to a kid's every move, and keeps them nice and cool for all their nap times! 

Highlights of the BB Kids

• Fiberglass Free, CertiPUR-US, and Greenguard Gold Certified to make sure your little dreamer is out of harm's way!
• Comes in Twin, Twin XL, and Full sizes; all 3 options are under $300!

What to Keep in Mind

• Not ideal if you want a softer or higher-loft mattress, since the BB Kids is only 6” tall.
• If you want to avoid an all-memory foam mattress, we recommend checking out the Signature Hybrid for a good-value mattress with plenty of customization options.

Dreamfoam Essential - Best Memory Foam Mattress

The Dreamfoam Essential is perfect for anyone looking for a high-quality memory foam mattress without spending a fortune. Available in a whopping 22 sizes and five height options, this mattress has sizes sure to fit in any space, whether it be a home or an RV. After discounts, the Dreamfoam Essential comes in under $1000 for all sizes and heights. The mattress layers body-contouring memory foam over a firmer foam for a balanced feel. 

Highlights of the Dreamfoam Essential

• 22 sizes, 5 height options, all under $1000… Need we say more?
• Ideal for back sleepers and memory foam lovers due to its high level of firm support and body contouring. 
• RV or Camper Owners will also enjoy this bed-in-a-box since it comes in RV-specific sizes (which is rare).

What to Keep in Mind

• If you prefer a bouncier mattress, this one wouldn’t be ideal for you since it has a slower response than other types of mattresses.
• Not ideal for heavier sleepers due to its level of support. We’d recommend checking out the Titan Plus!
• The Dreamfoam Essential is not ideal for side sleepers, since they require a bit more cushioning to help alleviate pain in the hips and shoulders.

Summary

Finding the right mattress can be a game-changer for your sleep quality and overall health. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. But don’t worry– Brooklyn Bedding has you covered with our top mattresses of 2024. Whether you’re looking for a luxurious hybrid, a cooling solution, or something extra firm, we have something for everyone.

Remember, quality sleep isn’t just about the hours you put in– it’s about how you feel when you wake up. Investing in the right mattress can make a world of difference. Take your time to explore our recommendations, and don’t hesitate to prioritize your comfort and support needs. After all, a good night’s sleep is one of the best gifts you can give yourself. Sweet dreams!