Review topics: ["replacement","fit","color","feels","support","size","quality","issues","delivery","weight","material","price","packaging","improvement","design","service","deal","looks","box","works","value","cover","foam","set","customer service","comfort","shape","use","height","case"].
Reviews
We bought two of these
"We bought two of these pillows, and there is a very noticeable difference in the amount of stuffing. My husband’s pillow is fully stuffed and properly firm. Mine is much less stuffed and fairly flat. I would give my husband’s fellow five stars, but mine I would only give two."
— Lauren C. (3/5)
The Brooklyn bedding pillow has
"The Brooklyn bedding pillow has made an incredible difference in my life. I had a large soft pillow and I was continuously manipulating it at night to have it adequately support my head. As a side sleeper, I was tempted by the wire cutter review and I am so glad I did. Ever since the pillow has been on the bed and under my head at night, I have slept better and more importantly, I have stopped snoring. Don’t take it from me, take it from my spouse. She is happier too."
— Ernie L. (5/5)
Excellent
"I recently ordered 2 queen size pillows. Unfortunately 1 arrived damaged. The side seam on 1 side was open and not sewn together. Amelia in customer service was awesome in offering to replace the damaged pillow. Many thanks to you for being customer focused. Love these pillows. So comfortable. Best sleep ever. We'll recommend to friends and family."
— Karen S. (5/5)
The BEST!!
"Not too hard, not too soft. Fluffs easily but rarely need to. And it has helped my painful neck. FYI I did my research on which type of pillow I should get for neck pain and that is why I selected the Premium Shredded Foam Pillow over all the other types available. I also feel that it is a fair price to pay."
— Susan R. (5/5)
Joy Erickson
"I love this pillow! Wasn’t really looking for a pillow but checked out Consumer Reports and it was highly rated. After a few weeks of using the pillow, took out a little of the shredded foam and it is much more comfortable and not as heavy. I love the idea of being able to create your own pillow. Thanks so much!!"
— Joy E. (5/5)
Five star, but through no fault of the pillow
"A good pillow, just that I'm a side sleeper with a messed up neck. Other than that, the pillow feels wonderful, has a comforting and soft texture; I've thied sleeping with no pillowcase, but the exterior began to string. Again, good pillow, but mostly doesn't fit my personal physical needs."
— stephen k. (4/5)
Too filmsy and flat
"The pillow doesn't have enough filling even though it's advertised as being shipped with a bit more than needed. As it stands, I cannot recommend the pillow for an average sized side sleeper. This pillow must be awful for a larger framed person. I'll reach out to customer support to see if they can send me more filling. If not, I'll return it."
— Michael C. (3/5)
A Tummy Sleepers Dream Come True
"Consumer Reports suggested that I purchase one of your pillows that allows filling to be removed. I am a tummy to side sleeper and thought that my neck would benefit from a much less lofty pillow. I did remove quite a bit of the filling, but, oh, what a difference. I sleep sounder at night and I think I even fall asleep faster, too. I am so grateful for this pillow. Thank you."
— Judi S. (5/5)
One of us likes it
"We bought 2 pillows. My head slips off at night and it's overstuffed and heavy. Hate it for sleeping but ok for watching TV in bed. Dad loves the pillow and the fit. He's much taller and heavier. It's a lot to spend for just an ok pillow. Dad thinks it's great. So it was worth it for one of us."
— Melissa M. (3/5)
Perfect fit
"The pillow was a bit too thick as it arrived, so I removed some of the stuffing to make it more comfortable. It is sufficiently cool and does not seem to heat up while sleeping on it. I like that the outer cover can be removed for washing."
— Gail G. (5/5)